We Can Now Scrap The Council tax

The Scottish government has introduced its Council Tax (High Value Dwellings etc.) (Scotland) Bill to Parliament. [1]

The Bill creates two new Council Tax bands I and J for dwellings valued at over £1-2 million (Band I) and over £2 million (Band J) as valued at a new valuation date of 1 April 2026. The English Mansion Tax proposals, by contrast, create a new and separate tax from the Council Tax.

Were it not for the fact that an updated bespoke valuation for these two new bands is reqiored at a cost of £10 million, these new bands could have been created through secondary legislation as I argued in a blog in September.

The only reason that primary legislation is required is that the Local Government Finance Act 1992 only provides a power to conduct a revaluation of ALL bands (such a revaluation has never been carried out). Because the new High Value Dwellings proposal requires the revaluation of only those properties in the new bands, primary legislation is thus necessary.

This seems a complete waste of Parliamentary time when there is a broad consensus that the Council Tax requires wholesale reform. If this Bill becomes law, the Council Tax will become more, not less, complex with two separate valuation dates for two separate sets of Bands.

I published draft secondary legislation that demonstrated how a proportional property tax based on up to date valuations could be introduced through secondary legislation. All that would be required for this to be successful would be political agreement between the Scottish Government and sufficient other parties to secure a Parliamentary majority.

Importantly, however, this Bill provides the opportunity to do the same thing (and go further) if MSPS so desire. Because it is a Bill, any MSP can lodge amendments – amendments which, if drafted in line with my proposals, would effectively scrap the Council tax. MSPs cannot, by contrast, propose amendments to secondary legislation.


Please read my September blog for full background and details. I do not propose to repeat all of the arguments again in this blog.

Parliamentary time is valuable.

There is now the opportunity to finally scrap the Council Tax

Are MSPs up for it or not?

Finally, it is worth noting that this is the first Bill introduced to Parliament that has been required to be accompanied by a statement as to whether, in the view of the MSP introducing a Bill, it is compatible with the European Charter of Local Self-Government. I will blog next week on this Bill which I introduced to Parliament in 2020 and which came into force on 16 October 2026.

NOTES

[1] The Bill and accompanying document can be downloaded from Scottish Parliament website. The various impact assessments are available as follows

Consultation Analysis
Strategic Environmental Assessment
Fairer Scotland Duty Assessment
Equality Impact Assessment
Child Rights and Wellbeing Assessment
Business Regulatory Impact Assessment
Island Communities Impact Assessment Screening